Diagnosing a Low Quality Score Without Guessing

A low Quality Score has a specific cause, not a general one, and finding it before you start changing things saves you from rewriting ad copy that was never the problem. What the score is built from and what it is not covers the mechanism; this article is the diagnostic order that follows from it, in the same evidence-first approach as the wider look at where a small Google Ads budget actually goes.

Read the three component statuses first

Quality Score is not a single opaque number to stare at. Google's own account tools break it into the three components it is built from, each rated as below average, average, or above average: expected clickthrough rate, ad relevance, and landing page experience. The diagnostic move is simple and skipped surprisingly often: check which of the three is actually flagged, and fix that one first, instead of touching the ad copy, the keyword list and the landing page all at once because the overall number looks bad. If only one component is flagged, changing the other two does nothing for the score and adds risk to things that were not broken.

This matters more than it sounds, because the instinct with a low overall score is to treat it as one problem with one fix: rewrite the ads, and hope the number moves. But a keyword can score below average on landing page experience while its ad relevance and expected CTR both sit at average or above. Rewriting the ad in that case spends effort on a component that was never the issue, while the actual flagged component, the landing page, goes untouched. Reading the per-component status before acting is what turns "the score is low" into "this specific thing is low," which is the only version of the question that has a specific answer.

If expected CTR is flagged

This component asks whether your ad is likely to get clicked when it shows for a given search. Google's own guidance for improving it centers on two levers: adding negative keywords, so your ad stops showing for searches it was never a good match for and would predictably not get clicked on, and testing more compelling ad copy against the keyword's actual intent. A first negative keyword list built around what is actually wasting spend does double duty here, because a keyword pulling in irrelevant searches drags down expected CTR for the same reason it drags down spend efficiency.

If ad relevance is flagged

This component asks how closely your ad's language matches the intent behind the search, not just the keyword. Google's own guidance points at aligning ad language more directly with search terms, and restructuring ad groups so each group holds keywords that share one intent rather than several. If an ad group has drifted into covering more than one idea, the test for how many keywords actually belong in one ad group is the same test that fixes ad relevance: can one set of headlines speak honestly to every keyword in the group. If it cannot, the group is the problem, not the ad copy inside it.

If landing page experience is flagged

This component is the one most tempting to skip, because it is outside the ads interface. Google's own guidance is concrete: fast load times, mobile-friendly design, and page content that actually matches what the ad promised and the search intended. A landing page that loads slowly or buries the thing the ad promised under unrelated content will show as below average here regardless of how good the ad copy above it is. This is also the component most likely to require a change outside the Google Ads account itself, which is worth planning for rather than expecting a same-day fix.

Working through more than one flagged component

Some keywords will have more than one component flagged below average at once, and the order still matters. Ad relevance and landing page experience tend to move together, because a search-to-ad-to-page chain that loses coherence at one link usually loses it at more than one; fixing the ad-group-and-language mismatch described above often improves both readings, since a tighter match between search intent and ad copy is also a tighter match between the ad and whatever the landing page needs to deliver. Expected CTR is more independent of the other two: a technically relevant ad and a good landing page can still under-perform on expected CTR if the ad copy itself is weak or generic, which is why negative keywords and copy testing stay a separate task rather than something the relevance fix resolves automatically. Work relevance and landing page together first if both are flagged, then treat CTR as its own pass.

What not to do: chasing the 1-10 number itself

It is worth repeating, because it changes how you should read your own progress: Google's own documentation states that Quality Score "should not be optimized or aggregated with the rest of your data" as a target in itself. Fixing the flagged component is the correct move. Watching the 1-10 number climb week to week as though it were a KPI is not, because the number is a lagging, diagnostic read on the components, not a lever you pull directly. If you fix the flagged component and the number does not move immediately, that is consistent with how the score is described to work, not evidence the fix failed.

FAQ

Should I fix all three Quality Score components at once? No. Check which component is actually flagged below average and fix that one first. Changing components that are already average or above average does not improve the score and adds unnecessary risk to parts of the account that were working.

What actually improves expected CTR? Negative keywords that stop the ad showing for searches it was never a strong match for, and ad copy that speaks more directly to the keyword's intent, per Google's own guidance.

What actually improves ad relevance? Matching ad language more closely to the actual search terms, and organizing ad groups so each one holds keywords sharing a single intent rather than several unrelated ones.

How long does it take for Quality Score to update after a fix? Google does not publish a fixed timeline. The score is built from historical data, so a fix reflects in the score gradually as new history accumulates rather than immediately after the change is made.

Checked against Google Ads' own "About Quality Score for Search campaigns" and "5 ways to use Quality Score to improve your performance" documentation, 2026-08-05. No account-specific campaign performance is presented as evidence in this article.

Similar Posts